Follow Us

Twitter

Why Do Police Announce DUI Checkpoints?

by Ethan Fry | Nov 20, 2012 6:13 pm

() Comments | Commenting has expired | | E-mail the Author

Posted to: Ansonia, Derby, Oxford, Seymour, Shelton, Police

It seems counterproductive: every year police step up enforcement of suspected drunken driving around holidays like Thanksgiving and Christmas.

They initiate roving road patrols. They plan DUI checkpoints at locations throughout the state.

But then they announce exactly what they’re doing — down to where and when the patrols and checkpoints will take place — seemingly giving advance notice to anyone thinking of driving drunk.

Why?

“Because the United State Supreme Court made a ruling and said we were obligated to do so,” Lt. J. Paul Vance, a state police spokesman, said Tuesday. “We’re obligated to follow the law like anybody else does.”

The mandate wasn’t always around, Vance said.

“We never used to announce them,” he said. “It was ‘Surprise!’”

That changed after a 1990 U.S. Supreme Court ruling in a case out of Michigan.

In that case the court ruled 6-3 that such checkpoints were constitutional. But in doing so, they implicitly acknowledged that certain guidelines — like publicizing the checkpoints ahead of time — were necessary.

If a person is driving, a police officer needs a reason to pull them over, or the stop would be illegal. Police advertise checkpoints as a way of giving fair notice to the general public.

“It’s required because otherwise it would be considered a detention without reasonable suspicion, which is a violation of the Fourth Amendment,” said John Williams, a New Haven defense lawyer.

As amendments go, the fourth — which protects citizens from unreasonable searches and seizures, and requires police to (in most cases) convince a judge to sign a warrant to search citizens — is a pretty important one.

In the 1990 case, the Michigan appeals court had ruled that DUI checkpoints violated the Fourth Amendment before the U.S. Supreme Court overruled, using a balancing act to determine that the dangers posed by drunk driving outweighed the Fourth Amendment intrusion.

Interestingly, when the case was sent back to the Michigan Supreme Court, justices there effectively side-stepped the U.S. Supreme Court decision by ruling that sobriety checkpoints violated their state constitution.

Ten other states, including Rhode Island, have similar bans on sobriety checkpoints, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. But not Connecticut.

NHTSA.GOV Guidelines issued by the NHTSA also instruct police departments to publicize checkpoints aggressively.

Williams said that in cases regarding the constitutionality of DUI checkpoints, courts hold that announcing them ahead of time helps police satisfy constitutionality requirements.

“If they didn’t announce it they would definitely be in trouble and they wouldn’t be able to use any of the results,” Williams said.

Vance said that despite the requirements to announce the checkpoints and patrols ahead of time, state police still arrest drunk drivers.

“It doesn’t impact our ability to enforce,” Vance said, pointing out that state police charged 65 people with drunken driving over the Thanksgiving weekend last year. “That’s pretty significant for one holiday.”

Vance also said that aggressive publicity regarding the checkpoints acts as a deterrent to drunk drivers. People reading or seeing about upcoming checkpoints may think twice about driving drunk as a result, he said.

Thanksgiving is especially important, Vance said, because it’s “the first major holiday where a lot of college students come home for the first time,” and police hope parents will remind them about driving safely.

A full list of state police patrols and checkpoints is embedded below. In the Valley, troopers from the state police Troop I barracks plan roving patrols on routes 15 and 8 Friday and Saturday.

2012 Thanksgiving DUI Roving Patrols Sobriety Checkpoints

Share this story with others.

Share |

Comments

posted by: Sennett Devermoney on November 21, 2012  5:07am

Publicizing DUI Checkpoints is part of the reason to conduct it. The promoting of it helps deter drunk driving. When people hear police setting up a checkpoint, many people decide to take responsible action in planning for a designated driver, not drinking, parting at home, or taking a last minute cab.

The service MrCheckpoint helps publicize these DUI Checkpoints by sending free text alerts. To receive the alerts text NODUI to 51515 or go to their website www.MrCheckpoint.com.

Check out their social media on twitter @MrCheckpoint!

posted by: David Stead on November 24, 2012  2:55pm

Or maybe DUI checkpoint lists are really a way of providing a “detour map” of sorts for all those drunks…how would you like it if the easiest way around a checkpoint was past your house where your kids were walking across the street?

Events Calendar

PosterWallAdd your Poster

Sponsors

Knight Foundation Valley Foundation The Community Foundation for Greater New Haven

Sponsors have no input into or responsibility for articles published on this site.

V.I.S. Site Design & Development

smartpill design