Derby Recount Results

Wikimedia Commons

Derby City Hall (Wikimedia photo)

DERBY — An automatic recount held in Derby City Hall on Sunday showed no changes in the winners, according to an email from Derby Town Clerk Marc Garofalo.

The recount happened because two contests during the Nov. 7 election fell within the margin that mandates a recount by state law.

Two contests qualified:
* The First Ward Aldermen/Alderwomen race, which saw Arthur Newberg, a Democrat, edge out Rich DiCarlo, a Republican, by nine votes
* The Board of Apportionment and Taxation race, which saw Republican Isa Simmons-Derby edge out Republican Robert Miller, Jr. by 15 votes.

The recount in the First Ward affirmed Newberg’s victory, according to the town clerk.

The Board of Apportionment and Taxation recount was not held because Miller declined, which is his right under state law.

Garafalo said complete results will be posted later today (Monday, Nov. 13). Be sure to check the town clerk’s Facebook page.

UPDATE: here are the results as distributed in email by the Derby Town Clerk:

Please find attached amended Head Moderator’s Return for the November 7, 2023 Election in the City of Derby after the recanvass.

The recanvass for the Board of Apportionment and Taxation was not conducted as Mr. Robert Miller, Jr. waived his right to the recanvass.

The recanvass for the Board of Aldermen/Alderwomen – 1st Ward resulted in slight vote changes but the final result was the same.

Original Results

Pettinicchi — 296

Widomski — 310

Newberg — 289

Pollastro — 248

DiCarlo — 280

Szewczyk – 256

Amended results after recanvass

Pettinicchi — 298

Widomski — 311

Newberg — 290

Pollastro — 248

DiCarlo — 280

Szewczyk – 256

The changes were from the machine counted in person poll ballots that resulted in one additional vote for Pettinichi, Widomski and Newberg and one additional vote for Pettinichi from the hand counted Election Day Registration. There were no other changes.

Thanks to all who participated.

Sincerely,

Marc J. Garofalo, MPA, MMC, MCTC — Town / City Clerk


Keep local reporting alive. Donate.ValleyIndy.org