Menchetti Wins Again!

Reigning paczki-eating champ Gentleman” Joe Menchetti won the Eddy’s Bake Shop pazcki-eating contest Tuesday morning.

He finished 10 paczki in five minutes. (See video below)

About a dozen people braved the weather to scarf the delectable Polish treat and compete for the chance to win $200.

Here are a few of their stories.

Name: Marcus Bartone
Hometown: Derby
Paczki Consumed: 7
Driving Force: Bartone’s 7‑year-old daughter Sydney died three years ago from a rare form of cancer called Neuroblastoma. For the past four years, Bartone and a crew of friends and family have competed in the paczki-eating contest to raise awareness for the cancer.
Quote: We kick off the campaign with a paczki-eating contest to make a fool of ourselves. You know, what better way of making awareness than making a fool of yourself.”

Name: Mike Crockett
Hometown: Ansonia
Paczki Consumed: 5 1/2
Driving Force: Crockett said some coworkers told him about the contest in years past, and this is the first time he got to attend.
Training Technique: Crockett ate 25 stuffed shells the night before.
Quote: (After competition) I feel fine. I’m ready for breakfast.”

Name: Joe Menchetti
Hometown: Wallingford
Paczki Consumed: 10
Driving Force: Menchetti wouldn’t consider himself a professional eater because he doesn’t make a living off of the contests he enters, but called himself world class.”
He has entered and won various contests, including dumpling, pizza, chicken wings and cicada, a flying insect.
Quote: I’m happy to win by a bite.”

Name: Judy Rodger
Hometown: Ansonia
Paczki Consumed: 1 (with one taken home for later)
Driving Force: She wanted to eat the paczki.
Training Technique: None.
Quote: I don’t want to get sick.”

Name: Kasey Matusovich
Hometown: Ansonia
Paczki Consumed: 4
Driving Force: Redemption. Last year Matusovich choked on the first bite and didn’t end up finishing the contest. This year, he was back and ready to prove himself.
Training Technique: Matusovich ate 30 buffalo wings at Buffalo Wild Wings the night before.
Quote: Kasey Case-Closed’ Matusovich is back baby.”

Click here for background on the contest.

Support The Valley Indy by making a donation during The Great Give on May 1 and May 2, 2024. Visit Donate.ValleyIndy.org.

Watch The Valley Indy Great Give Livestream at Facebook.com/ValleyIndependentSentinel.