SEYMOUR – Neighbors living in the town’s Great Hill section said they don’t want a cell tower near their houses on town-owned land.

About 30 people attended a meeting of the Seymour Board of Selectpersons Tuesday (Nov. 17). On the agenda – a potential cell tower at the Great Hill Hose Fire Co. at 140 Botsford Road.

During the meeting’s public portion session, 15 people spoke about the potential tower – two were in favor while 13 were against the idea.

“Cell towers do not belong in residential areas – you know it, I know it, we all know it,” said Marsha Schuck, a Seymour resident for 60 years. “I’ve supported any and all proposals and events that make this town better and I’ll continue to do that. But please don’t throw me, my neighbors and my neighborhood under the bus.”

Background

Earlier this year Verizon approached Seymour government looking for a spot to place a cell tower.

The town began exploring whether building a tower on town-owned land could generate revenue for Seymour. The town hired Airosmith, LLC, a telecommunications company, for $2,600, to search for a location.

The search ended with 140 Botsford Road, where a cell tower was previously opposed, as the top contender.

The address already has a 160-foot emergency communications radio tower on it. Seymour government is exploring whether to replace that tower with a 180-foot monopole cell tower and charge cellular companies to use it.

Seymour Finance Director Jason Vieira said at a previous public meeting that the town could potentially collect between $200,000 and $250,000 in annual revenue.

He estimated the cost to build the tower at somewhere between $300,000 and $500,000.

The Selectpersons want a concrete estimate on what it could cost to build, so on Tuesday they voted to issue a request for proposals. That is, they want companies in the cell-tower building business to send in documents saying how they’d build it and for how much money. 

First Selectwoman Annmarie Drugonis said the fact the town is exploring costs doesn’t make it a done deal.

“We have to determine the cost of the tower and then we’ll see if it makes sense to build it,” she said.

Neighbors: No Thank You

Resident Tom Bennett raised concerns about negative health impacts from cell towers, particularly radiofrequency radiation, or RF waves.

“It’s one thing that the (local) government is going to be in business with a company that makes billions of dollars off of this and they don’t care about our cell coverage – their bottom line is to make money,” Bennett said. “But we shouldn’t be subjecting people to possible health issues.”

However, federal law makes it difficult to reject a cell tower based on adverse health affects. The FCC sets the limit for RF emissions, and if a tower falls within the guidelines, it can’t be rejected for health reasons. 

Click here for a 2018 story from CBS News on the matter.

Regardless of the FCC guidelines, Seymour residents said they don’t want the tower.

Resident Linda Bandith also spoke in opposition. 

“Putting a tower there will come with radiation risks and that’s a risk we don’t want to take,” Bandith said. “There’s going to be a decline in our property values, and what about the noise?” Will the benefit outweigh the risks?”

Resident Jennifer Carangelo said her family spends a lot of time outside, and a cell tower in their backyard would not be a welcome addition.

“Not only would this be a visual impact, but we won’t get a decent sleep from the hum of the generator,” Carangelo said. “We are very upset about this and it’s going to change our way of life. We don’t want to leave Seymour, but this is going to be very disruptive.”

Seymour Schools Superintendent Susan Compton spoke in favor of the cell tower, as did Meagan Krushinski, the president of the teachers’ union. 

“Cell service at Seymour Middle School and Seymour High School is extremely poor, and it’s a safety issue,” Krushinski said. “A cell tower would provide another layer of communication and the financial benefit should also be considered.”

Seymour Middle School is located at 211 Mountain Road, not far from the proposed site. Seymour High School is also in the Great Hill section of town at 2 Botsford Road. 

Selectmen Scott Andrews and Al Bruno and Selectwoman Brianna Girard said the board isn’t going to rush into any decisions without fully vetting a proposal, the costs and any potential costs, benefits and risks. 

“We have to understand what the cost to the town will be and also what the cost to the neighborhood is,” Girard said. 

Same Site, Different Year

In 2014, AT&T wanted to put a cell tower at 140 Botsford Road and offered to pay $18,000 a year. That plan was met with opposition from the town and neighbors. It did not move forward. Click here for a previous story.

What’s Next

Seymour’s chief administrative officer Kurt Miller said the town plans to put out a request for proposals in the next week or two, and let it run for four to six weeks. He said the board should have proposals to review in late January or early February. 

Ultimately, the Connecticut Siting Council has jurisdiction over the placement of cell towers in the state. The local land use board can make suggestions and play an advisory role, but the decision ultimately rests with the Siting Council.


Plan now, give later, and impact tomorrow at ValleyGivesBack.org.